NOOZIFY

Film — Noozify Original — November 9, 2026

John Turturro Takes the Lead in 'The Only Living Pickpocket in New York'

By

Summary

  • Noah Segan's The Only Living Pickpocket in New York stars John Turturro as Harry Lehman, an aging pickpocket in a New York that has gone cashless, who lifts the wrong USB stick and has days to get it back from a crime family. It opened October 23rd and went nationwide on the 30th.
  • Turturro learned the trade for the role and gives a patient, restrained performance; Steve Buscemi and Giancarlo Esposito add texture as a pawnshop owner and a detective. The Associated Press reports Oscar buzz and a possible first nomination.
  • Noozify gives it an A−, with an A for acting, A− for directing, B+ for writing, and A− for production. The crime-family plot is familiar machinery, but the film is a quiet elegy for a city, and Turturro is the reason to see it.

Watch the story in half a minute

The writer-director Noah Segan's The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, which opened October 23rd in New York and Los Angeles and went nationwide a week later, stars John Turturro as an aging New York pickpocket in a city that has largely gone cashless. It is a small, character-driven film with a strong ensemble, and it gives Turturro the kind of leading role he has rarely been offered. Underneath the plot sits a question: what happens to a thief when the thing worth stealing stops being cash?

His character, Harry Lehman, works a city where wallets thick with bills have given way to credit cards that can be canceled in seconds. Harry is scraping by while caring for his disabled wife, Rosie, when he unwittingly lifts a valuable USB stick and passes it on. From there he has a narrow window to get it back before a vengeful crime family collects on the insult.

The setup reads like a caper, and the film does send Harry racing from Sheepshead Bay to Forest Hills and well beyond, but the chase is a pretext for something quieter. Nicolás Delgadillo of the site DiscussingFilm, writing after the Sundance premiere in January, titled his review "A Quiet Requiem for an Aging City," and the phrase fits. Subway platforms, pawn shops, and bodegas function here as the city's memory rather than as scenery.

Turturro is the reason any of this lands. He prepared by learning the trade, which he has compared to a magic act, as he explained in a Today show appearance. The skill depends on misdirection and on being overlooked, and he told the Associated Press that the idea resonated personally. "People don't look at you anymore," he said. That line is the key to the performance, a patient study of a man whose professional virtue is going unnoticed and whose home life demands the opposite.

It helps to remember where Turturro comes from. His Pino, the pizzeria worker in Do the Right Thing, and his bowler Jesus Quintana in The Big Lebowski were assembled, by his own account, from people he met around New York, and the 7 train seems to have been an especially generous source. Thomas Duffy, reviewing for the site FilmBook, calls him an "actor's actor" and argues that a rare leading role lets him show his most accomplished work yet. I would put it slightly differently. This is the most sustained look we have had at what he does when no one hands him a flamboyant tic to hide behind.

The supporting players are a pleasure, and much of the appeal is simply watching them work on home turf. Steve Buscemi, another Brooklyn-born veteran of the Coen brothers' films, plays Ben, a pawnshop owner, and Giancarlo Esposito, best known as the drug lord Gus Fring in Breaking Bad, plays Detective Warren, a cop whose path keeps crossing Harry's. Both carry the lived-in authority of performers who have spent decades absorbing the city's rhythms, and neither pushes for attention.

My reservations are small. This is a modest film, and viewers who arrive expecting the relentless propulsion the premise might suggest may find its mournful pace a mismatch. The crime-family menace is also a familiar piece of machinery, though Segan seems to know that and keeps his attention on the people the machinery grinds against.

Then there is the question every fall release invites. The Associated Press reports that Turturro's work has produced Oscar buzz, a rarity for an actor so beloved and so seldom honored, and that the film could land him his first nomination. My own guess is that a nomination is quite plausible. The Best Actor field tends to fill up late in the year with louder performances, but voters have a long habit of rewarding overdue veterans, and Sony Pictures Classics has a festival run through Sundance, Berlin, Toronto, and the New York Film Festival to build on. A win is a taller order, since quiet interior work is easy to talk past in a crowded race.

A pickpocket succeeds only while nobody is looking, and the same has been true of Turturro, an actor who, in the AP's phrasing, has always worked best when you don't see him working. The film asks us to look at both men at last, the thief the modern city has stopped noticing and the performer who made noticing him nearly impossible. Whether the Academy takes the subtle hint is the one sleight of hand left to watch.

Noozify's overall grade for The Only Living Pickpocket in New York is an A−, the average of four report-card grades on an A-to-F scale.

Noozify Report Card: The Only Living Pickpocket in New York
SubjectGradeComment
ActingATurturro anchors the film with a restrained, lived-in performance, and Buscemi and Esposito add texture around him. They all feel like people you would actually see on the streets of New York.
DirectingA−Noah Segan keeps the focus on character and city rather than chase mechanics, a confident choice for a filmmaker with a bright future.
WritingB+The script finds real feeling in Harry's plight, though the crime-family machinery is more familiar than fresh.
ProductionA−The outer-borough locations, from Sheepshead Bay to Forest Hills, give the film a lived-in sense of place that many bigger productions cannot buy.
OverallA−Converted to a four-point scale, the four grades come to 4.0, 3.7, 3.3, and 3.7, an average of 3.7, which rounds to an A−.