Martin McDonagh's 'Wild Horse Nine' Finds the Dark Comedy in a Coup
Summary
- Martin McDonagh's Wild Horse Nine, which opened in American theaters on November 6th, follows two CIA officers, played by John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell, who are sent from Santiago to Easter Island in 1973, shortly before the military coup in Chile.
- Malkovich won best actor at the Venice Film Festival, where the film drew a 13-minute standing ovation. It is a small, talky film, closer to a stage play than a spy thriller, and it was only the second film ever shot on Easter Island.
- Noozify gives it an A−, with an A for acting and an A− each for directing, writing, and production. The comedy turns into a confession, and the film leaves the viewer to decide what the laughter is worth.
The writer-director Martin McDonagh has spent three decades coaxing audiences into laughing at things they probably ought to find unbearable. His new film, Wild Horse Nine, which opened in American theaters on November 6th, poses the hardest version of that trick yet. Can a writer famous for profane, gleefully violent farce make a comedy about the overthrow of a democracy without cheapening either the laughs or the tragedy?
McDonagh came to cinema by way of the stage, and the habit of the playwright still shows. There was In Bruges with the actors Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson, then Seven Psychopaths, then Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri and The Banshees of Inisherin, which both premiered at the Venice Film Festival and collected multiple Oscar nominations. His strongest work tends to follow men stranded inside a difficult friendship, and this film is no exception.
The setup is simple enough to share without spoiling anything. It is 1973, and two CIA officers, Chris (John Malkovich) and Lee (Sam Rockwell), are sent from Santiago to Easter Island shortly before the military coup that ended President Salvador Allende's elected government in Chile. The production was only the second film ever shot on the island, and the cinematography treats the landscape as a bittersweet, almost ironic backdrop to the unease of the story.
The film very nearly became something else. McDonagh drafted versions about a father and son and about two actors, and none of them worked until he returned to the Chilean coup, a subject that had fascinated him since adolescence. Once he did, he told the Associated Press, the material turned into "something much deeper and sadder" than the comedy he first intended.
That depth rests on John Malkovich, who gives what may be the most carefully paced performance of his late career. Chris begins as a braying American abroad, and some of the early scenes are deliberately hard to sit through, but Malkovich lets the bluster thin out slowly until something far more fragile shows through. Time Out awarded the film five stars and singled him out above everyone else. At Venice in September the film drew a 13-minute standing ovation that left him visibly moved, and the festival jury went on to name him best actor.
If Malkovich supplies the weather, Sam Rockwell supplies the gravity. He is the one who keeps this two-man story from floating off into pure eccentricity, and the pair slide between brotherly squabbling and real tenderness so naturally that one reviewer felt they give Farrell and Gleeson a run for their money. Rockwell already has an Oscar from McDonagh's Three Billboards, and it is easy to see why the director keeps writing for him. Steve Buscemi as the pair's station chief, Parker Posey as Lee's wife, and the Chilean actress Mariana di Girolamo as a student fill out a supporting cast that never wastes a line.
Anyone expecting a conventional spy thriller should adjust the dial before the lights go down. This is a small, talky film, closer in spirit to a stage play than to a chase picture, where conversation does the work that gunfire usually does. The pleasures lie in the rhythm of the dialogue and in watching a friendship tighten under pressure, and a restless viewer may need a few minutes to settle into its pace. Once I had adjusted to the pace and tone of the movie, I was locked in and on its idiosyncratic wavelength.
Beneath the banter sits real history. The coup that ended Allende's government is the event these two men are helping to set in motion, and the film never lets the audience forget it. McDonagh says he set out to write only about Chile in 1973, and the parallels people now see were not planned.
McDonagh seems to have stopped trying to joke about a coup and started joking about a man who helped make one, and that shift changes everything. The humor becomes the anesthetic that lets a confession be spoken aloud, in what one critic calls a "Catholic guilt" approach that works as a slow poison rather than a shout. Whether laughter that eases a confession also eases a conscience is something the film wisely declines to answer. It is for you to decide, and it is why I have been thinking about this film for days.
Noozify's overall grade for Wild Horse Nine is an A−, the average of four report-card grades on an A-to-F scale.
| Subject | Grade | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Acting | A | John Malkovich's slow-burning transformation and Sam Rockwell's hilarious reaction shots to him make one of the best pairings McDonagh has put on screen. The supporting players make the most of small spaces, though Parker Posey could have been given more to do. |
| Directing | A− | McDonagh balances farce and sorrow with a steady hand and trusts silence as much as dialogue. |
| Writing | A− | The laughs in the script are as natural as the serious moments, and that is all credit to McDonagh's experience writing exactly this type of material throughout his career. |
| Production | A− | The Easter Island shoot, the period cars, and the photography give the film a sense of place well beyond its small cast. You will never see landscape shots of Easter Island as beautiful as the ones presented here. |
| Overall | A− | Converted to a four-point scale, the four grades come to 4.0, 3.7, 3.7, and 3.7, an average of 3.8, which rounds to an A−. |