Queens of the Stone Age Put Down the Riff on 'Perfecth'
Summary
- Perfecth, the ninth Queens of the Stone Age album, came out October 30th on Matador Records. It swaps the band's low, growling riffs for acoustic guitars, brighter tunings, and a bare voice.
- The change follows hard years for the frontman Josh Homme, including a divorce, cancer, and an emergency surgery in 2024, and it began with an acoustic set the band played in the Paris Catacombs that summer.
- Noozify gives it a B−, with a C for songwriting, B− for performance, B− for production, and B for vision. "Insignificant Other" is the standout, but too many of the other songs settle for a pleasant mood.
Queens of the Stone Age built a reputation on swaggering menace, which makes the hush at the center of their ninth album, Perfecth, a real surprise. It arrived October 30th on Matador Records and left me with a question I could not shake. What does a hard-rock band do when it no longer wants to be hard?
Some context for the skeptical. The album was produced by the frontman Josh Homme and the bassist Michael Shuman, and it was recorded in stretches between 2024 and 2026. I came to it as a listener raised on Rated R and Songs for the Deaf, so my ears were braced for low-tuned, riff-forward menace. That expectation turned out to be the first thing the record dismantled.
To understand why, it helps to know what Homme has endured. He and the singer Brody Dalle went through an acrimonious split in 2019, followed by a public custody battle, a stint in rehab, and cancer, which was removed by surgery in 2022. Speaking to the magazine Revolver in 2023, he called that stretch "the darkest four years of my life." Then came an unspecified emergency surgery in 2024 that forced the band to cancel its remaining tour dates, and he has said he spent the next seven months in bed.
Oddly, the band's creative pivot began just before that surgery, underground in Paris. In the summer of 2024 the band played an all-acoustic set in the city's Catacombs, the tunnels lined with the bones of millions of Parisians, and released it the following year. That stripped-down project left a clear imprint, and Neil Z. Yeung of the review site AllMusic describes the new album as "the most unfussy and human offering from the band to date." That is generous and also accurate, and for a hard-rock devotee it is a mixed blessing.
The practical consequence is a record that has traded weight for air. Queens are best known for a low, growling sound that comes from tuning their guitars two full steps below normal, but these songs are played in standard and brighter tunings, and the difference is audible within a minute. If you want the sneering torque of the band's 2000s records, you will find it only in brief, rationed doses.
The opener, "It's Only Love," is where the new temperament announces itself. Homme sits with an acoustic guitar while an elevated train rushes past, a scene that Rolling Stone's Jon Dolan places in a lonely apartment in the worst part of town. It is atmospheric and affecting, though it is hardly the sort of song that sends anyone scrambling for the volume knob.
The standout is "Insignificant Other," a loose, after-hours groove that wanders somewhere between lounge music and the funk of the 1970s Rolling Stones. One reviewer notes that it is reportedly the second of only two takes, which explains its unhurried charm, while another hears possible echoes of the divorce from Dalle in its wry, wounded vocal. It is the one place where the new approach and the old swagger fully shake hands.
A few other tracks are worth the detour. "Sunday" revives a song Homme first recorded with the punk pioneer Iggy Pop for the 2016 album Post Pop Depression, now given a disco-tinged pulse, and "Easy Street" brings in the country singer Nikki Lane over a gently strummed backdrop. "Where the Goth Girls At?" supplies the lone burst of menace, a thumping, squealing jolt that is welcome mostly because the surrounding songs are so restrained.
Thematically, the album circles love as a double-edged proposition, with friendship, grief, and repair orbiting nearby. The trouble is that several songs feel like what better Queens records would have treated as filler. Critics are split accordingly. On the review aggregator Metacritic the album averages 80 out of 100 across 17 reviews, while a reviewer at Sputnikmusic called it the limpest and most confusing album of the band's career. I land in the unglamorous middle. The album is admirable, sometimes lovely, and rarely thrilling.
Homme has framed the shift almost as a resignation. "I'm not a tough guy," he told GQ. "That's not what I'm trying to be." On first listen I heard a retreat, a band lowering its guard because it had run out of fight. But he is also the man who told an interviewer in 2023, "Perfection is really boring," and that remark hints at a different reading.
Volume is a form of armor, and a riff can disguise as much as it reveals, whereas a bare voice over an acoustic guitar leaves nothing to hide behind. Seen that way, a man who survived divorce, illness, and rehab and chose exposure over bluster has taken the tougher stance, even if it makes for a less thrilling record.
I still miss the thunder of the old albums, and this one will not displace them in my rotation. But I no longer hear a band gone soft. I hear one that has finally stopped performing toughness for an audience.
Noozify's overall grade for Perfecth is a B−, drawn from four report-card grades on an A-to-F scale.
| Subject | Grade | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Songwriting | C | The best material here, "Insignificant Other" and "It's Only Love" among it, shows Homme can still write a hook that sounds effortless. Too many of the remaining songs settle for a pleasant mood where a memorable idea should be, and the album's 36 minutes feel longer than they are. |
| Performance | B− | Homme's voice is the album's most expressive instrument, cracked and wry in a way the old records rarely allowed. The band plays with admirable restraint, but restraint is not the same as urgency, and the rhythm section is seldom given a chance to push back. |
| Production | B− | The sound is open, warm, and uncluttered, which suits the material and lets the quieter arrangements breathe. It also removes the low-end density that once made the band's records feel physically dangerous, and nothing quite replaces it. |
| Vision | B | This is a coherent, personal record that knows exactly what it wants to be, and I respect a veteran band for choosing exposure over repetition. The risk is that its coherence leaves little room for surprise, so the concept occasionally outruns the songs. |
| Overall | B− | Converted to a four-point scale, the four grades come to 2.0, 2.7, 2.7, and 3.0, an average of 2.6, which rounds to a B−. |