Music — Noozify Original — October 17, 2026

Sheryl Crow's 'Pick You Up': Seven Songs, Same Sun, Softer Light

By Adamo Cannizzaro

Watch the story in half a minute

In the spring of 2002, Sheryl Crow released a song that sounded like a car window rolling down. "Soak Up the Sun," written with Jeff Trott on a flight home while she was recovering from surgery and sent out that February as the lead single from C'mon, C'mon, reached No. 17 on the Billboard Hot 100 and spent the summer on every radio within earshot of a beach. Its trick was warmth. The guitars glowed, the chorus shrugged at money and worry, and the video put Crow on a surfboard off Oahu. Nearly 25 years later she and Trott are still writing together, and the first thing to say about Pick You Up, her new album, is that the window is still down. The second is that the view has changed.

Pick You Up came out October 9th) on Crow's own Old Green Barn label, with vinyl and CD editions to follow on November 20th. It runs seven songs and 25 minutes, every track co-written with Trott, and the two of them produced it at the barn studio on her property outside Nashville. It began life as a six-song EP and grew into an album when "Freedom Bus," a duet with the Arkansas folk singer Jesse Welles, was finished late and said what she wanted the record to say. It is her first album since Evolution in 2024, and only her second since she announced, in 2019, that Threads would be her last. She is 64, raising two sons in Nashville, and by her own account she now goes to songwriting to make sense of what is going on around her.

Put the title track on and the years fall away. A midtempo roots-rock strum, a guitar line that leans in on the chorus, and that voice, warm and unhurried, promising to come and get a friend who has had enough of the party. It could have sat on Tuesday Night Music Club in 1993 or on C'mon, C'mon in 2002, and that is the album's strength and its ceiling at once. Apple Music's editors hear "I've Got Your Number" as a direct descendant of "Soak Up the Sun," and they are right. The opener, "Freight Train," arrives on a weeping pedal steel, "Perfect" sways on acoustic guitar, and "Heaven Help Us" is the punchy, strummed Crow of her self-titled 1996 record. Not much has changed in her style over the decades, and I don't think she wants it to. What has changed is what she is singing about, and that is the only thing keeping the record from sounding like a reissue.

They have moved. The old carefree register is gone, replaced by something more accepting of a later stage of life, in the way Miley's Bass Persuades spent September working out what contentment sounds like. On "Pick You Up," the promise is modest on purpose. She will not fix anyone; she will show up with the car. "Perfect" admits she cannot make someone feel better and wants to try anyway. "Freight Train" turns a whistle heard across a dark neighborhood into a meditation on a loneliness that belongs to everyone at once, a post-pandemic mood that more than one reviewer picked up on. "Flat Earth" takes in a drought in the Amazon, a used Bible, and police tape, and admits, with a weariness that is the song's best idea, that the temptation is to pull the covers up and watch an old movie. These are insightful lyrics from someone who has stopped pretending the world is a beach. The catch is that the insight tends to arrive as a sentiment rather than a scene. The songs tell you how they feel more often than they show you a detail you will remember.

Then there is the bus. "Freedom Bus," the closing track and lead single, released August 15th with the album's announcement, is the one openly political song, and it is also the loosest and most fun, a singalong with Welles trading verses that Americana UK hears as a throwback to John Lennon's late-sixties Beatles songs. Crow told Billboard it grew out of a field trip with her son's eighth-grade class to Arlington National Cemetery, where the guide's stories left her thinking about what the freedoms we argue over cost the people buried there. The chorus asks, in blunter language than I will print, that people stop being jerks to one another and let everyone be, and it lands because she sings it with a grin rather than a lecture. It is catchy. So is the title track, whose chorus Americana UK called delightful and infectious, and so is "Heaven Help Us." But across seven songs the same midtempo strum and the same changes come around more than once, "Freight Train" never finds a real hook, and by the sixth track the record is repeating itself more than developing. You will hum it on the way out, though you may notice you are humming the same tune for three different songs.

Crow sings all of it beautifully, which has never been the question. Her voice has lost none of its warmth, and the band, with Trott on guitars, Fred Eltringham on drums, and a string arrangement on "Heaven Help Us,") plays with the restraint of people who have made this kind of record before. That restraint is also the problem with the production. Everything is clean, balanced, and familiar, and nothing surprises. Even "Flat Earth," the one track that reaches for grit, keeps its guitars politely in the mix. The playing and the production are never less than tasteful, and never once take the risk these songs needed.

And then it ends. Twenty-five minutes is a long EP rather than a short album, and two of the seven songs run under three minutes. Ultimate Classic Rock heard a record assembled quickly from the songs that happened to be finished, and musicOMH, in the harshest of the reviews, said it was over just as it found its stride. I agree with both. The frustration is not that the songs are bad; it is that the good ideas in them, the friend with the car, the train in the dark, the field trip to Arlington, get one verse and a chorus when they deserved a second thought. The album leaves you wanting more, and wanting more depth from what is already there.

Professional opinion has split the way you would expect over a pleasant record from a beloved artist. On Metacritic it holds a 60 from four reviews, every one of them filed as mixed. Riff Magazine gave it 7 out of 10 and heard Crow using her nineties vocabulary to address a lonelier present, musicOMH gave it two and a half stars and called it coasting, and BBC Radio 2 made it Album of the Week) for the week of October 12th. Nobody, as far as I can find, has called it a return to form, and nobody has called it a disaster.

My own verdict sits between them, and closer to the fans than to the skeptics. Pick You Up is a comfortable record by a woman who has earned the right to be comfortable, and whose way of being carefree, two decades on, is to accept what she cannot fix and show up anyway. I would have liked three more songs and a producer willing to push her somewhere the chords did not already know. As it stands, it is a warm afternoon that ends before you have finished your drink.

Noozify's overall grade for Pick You Up is a C+, the average of four report-card grades on an A-to-F scale.